I can barely express in words how much I
love Herman Melville’s Moby Dick.
This is a book I read first back when I was a teenager, shortly after watching
the movie (the one with Gregory Peck as Ahab). And that was after watching Jaws, which I didn’t, actually, like
very much. After all, the shark in Jaws
wasn’t exactly walking up on to the beach to eat people, was it? Why did they
have to go into the water if they didn’t want to be eaten?
I’d better explain that though I watched
both Moby Dick and Jaws in the movie theatres (in the same
movie theatre, actually) that shouldn’t be taken as an indication of my age. That
would have been quite a time-travelling feat, in any case, since Moby Dick was released in 1956 and Jaws in 1975. Until the mid-to-late
1980s, foreign movies usually arrived on Indian shores years to decades after
they were released in their countries of origin. That is why I could watch both
these flicks in the early 80s on the big screen. Not that there was any other
option, TV in India being something which mostly came into existence in 1982,
let alone such unimaginable luxuries as VCRs.
As I said, though, Jaws – though it was amazingly popular then, running in the theatre
in town for something like seven or eight weeks if I remember – wasn’t a film I
liked. I still don’t. Oh, the jump scares were nice – especially the scene
where the shark surfaces in the wake of the Orca and Brody decides they need a
bigger boat. You know the scene I’m talking about. But I was rooting for the
shark.
Those of you who have been reading me for a
while will be overwhelmed with lack of surprise that I was rooting for the
shark.
One of the reasons that I rarely to never
watch creature features is that I’m always hoping (usually against hope) for
all the human characters to be eaten or crushed or otherwise finished off in as
grisly a manner as possible. Especially
the kids. There are few things in the movies quite as irritating as kids in
creature features. Remember the two in Jaws
who decided to snorkel along the beach with a fake shark fin?
Now when I went to watch Moby Dick, you understand, I hadn’t read
the book. I didn’t know the story. I was actually expecting the whale to be
killed off, like the shark was in Jaws,
like any other Hollywood creature feature treated the titular animal(s). I go furious watching the Pequod’s crew murdering the (black) sperm whales
earlier in the film – yes, that’s right, furious – and I was hoping they’d at
least get some kind of comeuppance before they “raised and killed” Moby Dick.
I did not expect that it was Moby who would
kill them instead.
I still remember wiping my eyes furtively
when the movie was over, and they were tears of joy.
To this day, a recurrent feature in my
stories with animals (such a recurrent feature that it’s become pretty much
predictable) is that the animal, inevitably, triumphs over the human. I’ve also
written two stories which are sequels to Moby
Dick – one from the viewpoint of Moby himself, years after the events of
Melville’s novel, and the second set in modern days, where an immortal Ishmael
still pursues an immortal Moby, to the detriment of innocents who get in the
way.
But that was just the part about the hunted
animal exacting full and satisfying vengeance on his pursuers. After a couple
of rereading of the book, I’ve come to appreciate it on a much different level.
I’m not talking about the alternate chapters forming a treatise on whaling,
which I read the first time and then skipped on each subsequent rereading. I
mean Captain Ahab’s insane quest after the White Whale, a quest of revenge for
his missing limb...which was missing
because he had gone to murder the whale in the first place.
Just think about this a moment. Someone
sets up a situation that causes themselves suffering. They then go out for
revenge for that suffering, pursuing that vengeance to the point of their own
destruction – none of which would
have happened if they hadn’t begun the cycle in the first place by doing
something they had no need to do and no business doing. Even when given the
opportunity, over and over, to pull back from the brink, they choose to pursue
the course of vengeance, and that can have only one end.
Isn’t this all too like the course of a lot
of world events of the last quarter-century?
One of the things about Moby Dick (the
whale, not the book) is how rare peaceful
pictures of the animal are. After all, Moby wasn’t hunted round the clock,
seven days a week. Almost all the time, he would have lived a life much like
any other sperm whale, swimming, diving deep to hunt squid, mating with female
whales, echolocating in the depths, and the like. Yet it seems to be that all
depictions of him focus only on his fights against the Pequod’s crew – as though he existed only as an engine of violence,
nothing else.
And that’s why I painted this little
picture of Moby: not lashing the sea in frenzy as in just about all the
paintings I’ve seen online, but Moby as he deserves to be, swimming peacefully
in the inky ocean depths as he goes about his life in peace.
He deserves it.
Title: Moby
Material: Acrylic on Stone
Copyright B Purkayastha 2015
I like your post about Moby Dick far better than I liked the book when I read it. I rarely hate a book, but I did that one. Occasionally I think I should give it another try now that I'm an adult, but reading it the first time was so traumatizing that I'm, if you will, afraid to go back in the water.
ReplyDeleteI almost always root for the creature. (The sole exception I can think of is the first two Alien movie, when I identified with Ellen Ripley and didn't want her to die.) But aside from that, I always root for the monster/dinosaur/shark/whatever.
ReplyDeleteYes, I am less than staggered with surprise that you rooted for the shark. I'm not sure why I root as I do, but you may have put your finger on it when you said the animals are just swimming or buzzing around, minding their own business and people come and try to kill them. Or do something to provoke them and then kill them.
Not unlike our national security policy.
Bill,
ReplyDeleteI like the way you describe old Ahab and his quest for vengeance. Yes, HE caused his own loss of limb, but refuses to admit anything was his own fault. Well, he was the captain of an American whaling ship.
OK, maybe I am being a bit over harsh on poor old 'Merikkka. People are people the world over and the actions of Ahab could have made him a native of any country, any ethnic group. People, they are the cause of so much human misery.
Bill, Every time I read a story in the papers about an animal that kills a human - as you say, either its tormentor or someone invading and wrecking its home - I cringe, knowing that vengeance will be wreaked on the perpetrator and anything close by. We are also big fans of Moby Dick. Loved the image of you weeping tears of joy at the end of the movie.
ReplyDelete