Saturday 31 May 2014


This is not a happy article.

This is an article filled with anger. This is one of the times I am totally and completely furious – but not the way you’d think. No.

Probably I should explain.

If you remember, back in December 2012, India had been “shaken” by mass protests against a particularly gruesome rape-murder in Delhi. I’d written about it at the time. The protestors marched on the streets, beat a policeman to death, organised text message campaigns demanding the death penalty for the rapists, and polluted the air with the smoke from their candlelight vigils.

The story was repeated in August last year, when a young journalist was gang-raped on the premises of an abandoned textile mill in Bombay. Once again, the Muddle Class was exercised, and the media went to town on the rape for all it was worth.

After all, this is the nation where forensic medicine textbooks still say women shouldn’t be trusted in their accounts of being raped and fairly recently a judge acquitted some rapists on the grounds that they were middle-aged and “rape is committed by teenagers”. So it’s a good trend, you’d have thought, if the country was finally rising up in anger against rape and sexual assault.

You would be wrong.

On the 27th May, three days ago as I write this, two cousins, girls aged 14 and either 15 or 16, went missing in a village in the badlands of Uttar Pradesh state in North India. Their corpses were discovered the next day, hanging from a mango tree in an orchard near the village. They’d both been gang-raped before being killed – and the local police was hand-in-glove with the rapists.

Actual photograph of the scene

 You’d think the country would erupt with anger, wouldn’t you? You’d think the people would be in the streets again, demanding justice?

Apart from the local people, the parents and other villagers, who knew perfectly well who was responsible and who refused to let the bodies be removed till the perpetrators were arrested, just about no one was interested – except for some politicians looking for publicity. The media reported it, but only as filler news. On the net, by my own experience, foreigners were more disturbed and appalled than Indians were.


Not a mystery.

Let me quote what I’d said back in December 2012:

(T)he Great Indian Muddle Class ... sees itself as superior to the masses from which it has emerged, and it aspires to separate itself from them as far as possible. Unlike the middle class in other parts of the world, it doesn’t see itself as preyed on by the upper class; the upper class is its ideal, the realm to which it aspires....

On the other hand, the Muddle Class hates and fears the underclasses. It feels threatened by them – by their increasingly uppity demand for a place in the sun and by their competitiveness. To the Muddle Class, the underclass isn’t PLUs (People Like Us) – they are PLTs (People Like Them). It’s the underclass who threaten the Muddle Class’ upwards march. It’s the underclass which reminds the Muddle Class of the morass from whence it sprung, and where it’s terrified of returning.

So when six members of the underclass rape a woman of the Muddle Class, it’s not a crime against an individual woman. It’s a strike against the Muddle Class. Think of it as a serf raising his hand against a nobleman, and you won’t be far from the idea.

...It’s an absolute certainty that if the victim of the rape had been of the labourer set, there would have been as little reaction from the Muddle Class as there is when (as happens routinely) rich kids driving SUVs get drunk and crush homeless people to death. The Muddle Class doesn’t care about anyone but itself.

Accordingly, whatever the “protests” appear to be, they are not actually against the rapes – they are protests against the Muddle Class being made to feel vulnerable. No more, no less.

The victims in this latest episode were of the lowest castes, “Dalits”, who were once known as “Untouchables”. The perpetrators are Yadavs, further up the caste system but still pretty far down the totem pole. Both the victims and the victimisers are a world away from the air-conditioned malls and McDonalds of the Great Indian Muddle Class. If the Muddle Class thinks of them at all, it is with an unfathomable contempt.

And that is why these two girls don’t exist as far as the Muddle Class is concerned. It’s still basking in the electoral victory of its Hindunazi heroes, it’s looking forward to its promised “achche din” (good times), and the death of two of the members of the Lower Depths is about as irrelevant as it can get so far as the Muddle Class people are concerned. It doesn’t, after all, reflect on them, and that’s all they’re concerned about.

And this is why I am furious. Not at the rapists, as you might think – they’ll get what’s coming to them, never fear. I am furious at the Muddle Class, at the swine who were screaming for justice a year and a half ago but who are so deafeningly silent now. Where is your sense of justice, your outrage? Where are all your Facebook campaigns and candlelight vigils? Does it only affect you when you feel threatened? What kind of “outrage” is that?


I spit on the lot of you.


  1. By the way, some 70% of my photos, by a rough estimate, have gone missing from this site. I really don't feel up to posting them again, especially since I deleted a lot after posting. I'm looking for a new site. Suggestions welcome.

  2. What an excellent post! I am going to let this comment stand all by itself. Well written.

  3. The parallel in the US: white kids are gunned down in a college town in California and white kids are gunned down an elementary school in the eastern US and we are all outraged, holding candle vigils, you know the drill. But in our inner cities, black kids are gunned down every single offing day due to our drug and gun laws and they don't get a mention on the evening news. We white Americans are appalled that we could (more and more likely these days) be shot on our way to the Mall, but not so much that kids in Detroit sleep in bathtubs to be protected against stray bullets.

    And, of course, it's ok with us that a teenager in Lebanon or Yemen can be blown up by a drone, because that is part of the war on terror. (Or is that war BY terror?) Either way.

    "Not one more!" says a grieving father in California. I'll buy that. Not one more - anywhere.

    1. I was actually thinking of including a parallel to the comparison between black-on-black inner-city crime and "mainstream" crime in the US, but thought better of it, since it's not directly associated with the thrust of this post.

  4. and btw the whine ass american dad is a fake crisis actor

  5. I'm at a loss for words!!!
    When will it ever end?????
    There was this news two days ago...

  6. Bill,
    Absolutely. We should all be outraged at this vile crime. Your Muddle Classes in India are so much like what passes as either "liberals" or "Bible thumpers" here in the US of A. They are all hypocrites and I despise them all. They only care about their own selves and their "class". Actually none of them have any real class at all.
    Yes, the US is so "shocked" when "nice white kids" are shot down, but when Black or Hispanic kids are shot down, the response of the "liberals" and the "holy xtians" tend to be; well, they should have moved to a better area or it was their own fault or they were probably drug dealers or some such goddamn crap.
    The hypocrisy of what passes as "liberal", "progressive", "leftist" in the US of A is as bad if not worse than that of the "holier than thou" xtians.
    I detest all these damn fool colored bands that supposedly show the wearer as being for some "good project or cause". Big damn deal, it is ALL just for show and then they toss in various "celebrities" to support the cause, it makes any sane, rational human being sick.
    Thank you for posting this article. Your outrage IS shared by others Bill, trust me on this. I kept waiting for the mass protests after I saw this story on a news site I trust. What became of that? Nothing, just nothing at all, as you point out so clearly. Shame on the Muddle Class, they have NO class at all. Goddamn hypocrites, man I despise that vile sort of critter.

  7. I have to say, Bill, that the feelings of the Muddle Class in India and their utter fear and contempt for those under them in the class pecking order are very much like that of the U.S. middle class. And it's most nauseating embodiment is the so-called American 'feminists' who support imperialist war, believing that their country is wasting the rest of the world in its concern for women's rights in those countries. Now that will turn your stomach.

  8. thanks for the insight Bill - you've explained something that has been inexplicable in the social psyche of more than just India.


Full comment moderation is enabled on this site, which means that your comment will only be visible after the blog administrator (in other words, yours truly) approves it. The purpose of this is not to censor dissenting viewpoints; in fact, such viewpoints are welcome, though it may lead to challenges to provide sources and/or acerbic replies (I do not tolerate stupidity).

The purpose of this moderation is to eliminate spam, of which this blog attracts an inordinate amount. Spammers, be warned: it takes me less time to delete your garbage than it takes for you to post it.